Joanna Wilton's husband, George, is accused of killing Harry Slade, who's her personal trainer and her lover. George asks Matlock to defend him, but Ben is reluctant to do it, since Wilton did a terrible job on replacing his roof, which now leaks like a sieve whenever it rains. Ben agrees to defend after he promises to repair his roof ASAP. The problem is, Ben discovers the case is a lot more complicated than he thought, as the slain trainer not only had a lot of lovers, which provides a lot of possible killers, but that George also was unfaithful as well.