I'm not a regular Gunsmoke viewer, although I've seen at least a couple of dozen episodes in my life, even going back to when it was first run in the 70s when I was a kid. I grew up a Bonanza fan and Gunsmoke wasn't as fun for me to watch I guess. I came across this episode because I set up my DVR to record anything with Charles Gray. A funny story here is I watched the whole episode looking for "Charles Gray" the English actor from James Bond and Rocky Horror Picture Show fame not realizing there was an American actor named Charles Gray also! This is not the first "comedic" Gunsmoke I have watched but it is the second one (the first comedic one I watched was 1971's Captain Sligo), and I see by other reviews it is considered a rarity. Everyone else has commented on the rape plot aspect and I agree, I was actually wondering what happened (was it rape or something less?) until a few more lines of dialog were spoken and even then it's pretty nonchalant. Then Festus kills the guy, who's played by Charles Gray (of course! Lol), in cold blood. I was glad Festus didn't give Mayblossom the level when she was leaving as that would have reminded her of the rapist, I'm surprised he kept it for himself since it came from the rapist, but no one seems to care too much, like its just some sort of a thing in those days around Dodge City. One strange episode for me. I'm surprised this episode rates so high (almost an 8), I found the soundtrack very loud, repetitive and annoying, and the "humor" of Mayblossom got old fast too. 6 of 10 is, for me, being generous, but it got me to write a review so it's definitely a memorable episode I wont forget. I'm surprised it was in black and white in 1964 since Bonanza had been in color for 5 years already. I guess CBS losing out on the color TV system wars to RCA (which was the owner of NBC, Bonanza's network) was slow to adopt it? I bet those CBS execs in the 1970s to 2000s really regretted not adopting to color earlier because it kept black and white programs like earlier Gunsmokes off of syndication for decades. Now I know there are two Charles Grays too, even though Xfinity doesn't know this (they have the English actor's pic on the DVR settings)!