I don't think there is a more unsympathetic "protagonist" in the entire series than Herb Phinney. I know the plot outline describes the story from the perspective of his wife Lucretia. But I will point out that the name of the episode references him, the Rainbow Chaser, and the beginning of the episode heavily emphasizes Herb, his actions and dreams. I am a little shocked this episode got made because of how unflattering it was of Herb, not all in keeping with the show's formula. But, I must concede this was early in the series, probably before it was so strictly defined. I can't recall another Death Valley Days' episode of a protagonist that lived so callously and unapologetically. Not that his actions were so egregious but one would certainly expect better behavior from a father who was the protagonist of a teleplay. Herb seems oblivious to the privations his dream chasing causes his family, telling Lucretia to simply get things from the store on credit. But what I am most astounded by is the favorable rating this has received by so many IMDb voters. I suppose their appreciation could be described as coming from the fact this story did not follow the usual "O. Henry" development so many Death Valley Days episodes follow. Maybe there is an element of delight in the absence of a morality tale. Let's not kid ourselves. Every tale is a morality tale. Even if the moral is nothing more than, "Don't be too certain you know what the truly moral choice was for the character." This story starts off extolling the man as The Rainbow Chaser and then proceeds to have him be, not a rainbow chaser, but an egomaniac who cares nothing for his family's welfare.