Dilemma (2005) Poster

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A fine short.
Boba_Fett113814 September 2008
All inconsistencies and imperfections aside, this is simply a fine and enjoyable short from Boris Paval Conen.

Basically it's very hard to create a perfect short movie. You never have enough time to develop your characters or to set up a proper story. This means that you need to rush things in order to tell what you want with your story and movie. This times goes at the expensive of the logic in the story, which is also certainly the case with this movie.

The story basically isn't explained within the movie. Time stops when a boy almost gets hit by a big truck, except for one man who witnesses it all happening. Why this happens for this one man never gets explained within the story and how certainly also doesn't get explained. I see the movie as about one that shows that everything is happening for a reason, not sure if this also was the message which the writer/director of the movie tried to send out.

It's a greatly shot and beautiful looking movie, despite not being set at the most beautiful location imaginable. It's obviously not just an 'amateur' short but all those involved are professionals within their business. Director Boris Paval Conen previously made the TV-series "De 9 dagen van de gier", set in Rotterdam, which also was a beautiful shot movie and made Rotterdam look like New York City. Seems like he is a man who knows how to handle a visual style and to tell a story. Unfortunately he works mostly on short movies and TV projects and he hasn't found his big break through yet. Or perhaps this is also his own choice and he wants to remain as much independent as possible as a film-maker and therefore sticks to short projects instead, in which he remains in total control of.

It's only 10 minutes short and it's certainly worth your time. Also if your not into 'foreign' movies or reading subtitles, don't be scared off, since this movie features zero dialog in it.

8/10

http://bobafett1138.blogspot.com/
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Superior short film.
Mozjoukine2 September 2006
This wide screen Dutch one reeler shows more imagination and sophisticated film technique than most programs of short movies.

The jogger is passed by the boy on the bike among the motorway pillars and tree stumps. He sees the bike boy about to be run down by a truck and time appears to freeze, giving the runner a chance to investigate the possibilities in three dimensions.

The layering is impeccable, with no hint of digital texture or outline, and it is used tellingly as with the falling apple.

The content is slight but this one knows how long to play it. And here's another line to bring this up to length.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Amazing!
fijep12 November 2014
Amazing concept well written and very good production! I saw it 8 years ago and was looking for it ever since! Why do I need to write 10 lines of text to submit my review I don't get it. This film is a short film and the actors are not speaking at all which is very difficult to pass a meaningful concept. This film has both. Amazing concept well written and very good production! I saw it 8 years ago and was looking for it ever since! Why do I need to write 10 lines of text to submit my review I don't get it. This film is a short film and the actors are not speaking at all which is very difficult to pass a meaningful concept. This film has both.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
well crafted
Kirpianuscus26 February 2019
The theme of frozen time is not original. But, in this case, it works in beautiful manner. First - because you feel the thoughts of the lead character. Nuance by nuance, scene by scene. Because , from the beginning of the second part, you know the end. And you hope be other. The apple is the key. Because the film is reflection of a parable about the most significant things defining us. So, a well crafted work.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed