The Eagle of the Ninth (1977) User Reviews

The Best Screen Version Of A Classic 1950s Children's Novel

[dennis nicoll · 8/10 · 3 August 2018]

Yes, this production must certainly have been networked by the BBC on the original transmission date as I welll remember watching it back in 1977 (and was living in the west of England at that time). Very well done in all respects - though perhaps the relationship between Roman officers and soldiers (even in an Auxiliary cohort) was portrayed as a little too familiar. This would not have been the case at the time. Roman society was deeply differentiated by class and social status and this would have been even more marked in a military context.

I read the novel as a child back in the 1950s (I have always been a great admirer of Rosemary Sutcliff's novels) and well remember the superb 1957 BBC radio serialisation (now lost) of the book by Felix Felton, broadcast on Children's Hour.

Just as a point of interest, we now know (from archaeological excavations) that Isca Dumnoniorum (Modern Exeter) was originally founded as the base of Legio II Augusta (49-73 CE) and that by the second century (when this story is set) had been abandoned by the Roman army and become a civilian settlement) the new Cantonal capital of the Domnonian tribe.

No matter, this and some other historical anomalies do not detract in the sightest from the story. I am also pleased that the serial has now been released on DVD and may be enjoyed by a new generation of viewers.

I remember this from my childhood

[robwilliamstn · 9/10 · 5 June 2018]

Had looked for it a long time on DVD, just found it on Amazon UK, which is what brought me here.

To the other reviewer - yes it was shown in the South of the UK. I lived in the Midlands at the time and recall talking to my brother about it when it broadcast.

It followed the book very well as I recall (unlike, say, the Eagle remake) even down to the dialog.

I'm getting all nostalic to see it again.

Was this shown south of the border?

[gb901 · 8/10 · 16 March 2018]

I would have been 9 when this was shown and most definitely something I would have watched - however I cant for the life of me recall it! Being a BBC Scotland production, I wonder, as living in east anglia, if this wasn't shown in my area?

It Resonates True to the Original Novel by Rosemary Sutcliff

[Strivingforfairness92 · 10/10 · 3 July 2017]

Chances are that conversion from novel to screenplay will bring a tragic loss of thoughts from the narrator and major characters. However, BBC Scotland's 1977 six-episode television version of Rosemary Sutcliff's 1954 novel manages to keep a delicate balance between a thoughtful story about the meaning of being humane while entertaining us cinematically in 117 A.D. Roman Britannia. Only the 1976 British TV series of Robert Graves' novel, I Claudius, is as engrossing.

The 2011 film, The Eagle, another version of the Sutcliff novel, eliminated the love story and the hero's fondness for his dog (or wolf), "Cub." In doing so, the 2011 version destroyed the novel's charm that should have carried over. However, the 1977 series transitions Sutcliff's writing perfectly. The production design, costumes, music and acting are also spot on. The detail for props is outstanding, e.g. a sophisticated Roman scissors hangs on a wall behind Marcus in Episode One.

The ensemble of actors includes fine performances from a young Patrick Malahide as Cradoc, the rebellious Caledonian, and Gillian Bailey as Cottia, the love interest of the hero, Marcus.

Anthony Higgins' performance in the lead role pleased novelist Sutcliff so much that she kept a framed photo of the actor in costume on her desk, it is said, until the day she died, as he brought Marcus to life just as she had hoped he would. Higgins is at the top of his game in this role. He's young, confident and strong; he carries the entire program on his shoulders.

The character's determination to exert his passion for life, while comporting himself as a noble Roman officer should, is fascinating. His ambition to recover The Eagle, symbol and standard for the vanished Ninth Legion, (of which his father was one), is limitless.

Higgins told a story about the power of the 1977 version of Eagle of the Ninth at Comic Con in Munich in April 2017. He said, "A couple of years ago, I was doing a movie in Malta about the life of Napoleon. We had an expert historian with us, who knew every button, feather and decoration that anyone of that period would have worn.

"He said to me, 'You know, you're to blame. When I was a kid, I saw Eagle of the Ninth and became obsessed with it. It made me want to learn everything I could about Roman armies, uniforms and weapons. That led me to go to Cambridge to study history. It's all because of you that I ended up there— because you did Eagle of the Ninth.'"

Higgins continued, "With all humility, an actor is just a sign for telling a story. What's amazing is the resonance that can unintentionally result."

Yes, its lasting effect rings true and clear. I'm delighted to have seen this program in its entirety and if you as a viewer come across it, consider yourself very lucky. It's captivating and worthwhile.

True to Rosemary Sutcliff's magnificent prose

[cmsdtspectacles · 10/10 · 20 October 2018]

At long last the BBC famed series has been released on DVD! For our contemporary tastes, the writing may take some time to enter the heart of the matter, but it's true to the pace and charm of the original novel to the last bit of dialogue.The first part let us into the minds of the characters, feeling, experiencing and growing with each of them. Stellar acting carries the tale in the first three episodes (short budget is obvious, but the filming is very skilfully done), before "the hunt begins". Every character should be named, but a young Anthony Higgins is a truly perfect Marcus (Rosemary Sutcliff herself thought so!) and Christian Rodska, a very touching and fierce Esca. Patrick Holt shines as an astute Aquila, as does Gillian Bailey, a feisty and beautiful Cottia. They add a lot to their short screen appearances, and so does Victor Carin: he is a truly magnificent Guern (he nearly steals every scene.) Highly recommended.

Classic

[wmcauliffe-00425 · 10/10 · 26 October 2020]

Loved the book when i first read it as a child in the 70's and thankfully didn't have to wait long to see the series shown in Australia. Rosemary is still one of my favorite authors and i love everyone in this series. Marcus and Esca are great and i even named my dog after Esca-and she was a girl. Best version. Glad i now have it on DVD.