 | Valerie Cossart | ... | Mrs. Cratchit (7 episodes, 1953-1954) |
 | Harry Townes | | (5 episodes, 1953-1955) |
 | Mildred Dunnock | | (5 episodes, 1954-1955) |

| Carmen Mathews | | (4 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Nancy Marchand | ... | Charlotte (4 episodes, 1954) |
 | Ed Binns | | (3 episodes, 1953-1955) |
 | Una O'Connor | | (3 episodes, 1953-1954) |
 | Leueen MacGrath | ... | Anne (3 episodes, 1953-1955) |
 | John Baragrey | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Sally Chamberlin | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | June Dayton | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Tom Helmore | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Murray Matheson | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |

| Roddy McDowall | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Claudia Morgan | ... | Eustasia (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Gaby Rodgers | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Polly Rowles | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Nydia Westman | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Joseph Wiseman | | (3 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Anthony Ross | ... | Narrator (3 episodes, 1954) |
 | Murray Hamilton | | (2 episodes, 1953) |

| E.G. Marshall | | (2 episodes, 1953-1955) |
 | Alexander Scourby | | (2 episodes, 1953-1955) |
 | Sylvia Sidney | | (2 episodes, 1953-1955) |
 | Bramwell Fletcher | | (2 episodes, 1953-1954) |
 | Colin Keith-Johnston | | (2 episodes, 1953-1954) |

| Cloris Leachman | | (2 episodes, 1953-1954) |
 | Noel Leslie | ... | Ebenezer Scrooge (2 episodes, 1953-1954) |
 | Frank McHugh | | (2 episodes, 1953-1954) |

| Ed Begley | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Leora Dana | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Constance Ford | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Jerome Kilty | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Phyllis Love | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Biff McGuire | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Katherine Meskill | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Dan Morgan | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Allen Nourse | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Elizabeth Ross | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |
 | Ernest Truex | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |

| Joanne Woodward | | (2 episodes, 1954-1955) |

| Art Carney | | (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Janet De Gore | ... | Dee (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Conrad Janis | | (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | E.A. Krumschmidt | | (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Jack Livesey | ... | King Arthur (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Gene Lyons | | (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Joe Maross | | (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Darren McGavin | | (2 episodes, 1954) |
 | Arthur O'Connell | | (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Woodrow Parfrey | | (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Carl Reiner | ... | Sir Kay (2 episodes, 1954) |

| Lin McCarthy | ... | Capt. Anderson (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Larry Gates | ... | Leonard (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Cameron Prud'Homme | | (2 episodes, 1955) |