Honey and Ashes (1996) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Review of 'Honey and Ashes'
philippacotton200014 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Variety described 'Honey and Ashes as "Edgy, intelligent...a passionate statement about the condition of women in the Arab world". This captures the film perfectly.

The film follows the lives of three young women in a North African Islamic country and their struggle in a patriarchal society between their desires and the obligations of their culture.

The youngest of the women is Leila, who is in love with a young man already engaged to his cousin. In her attempt to hide the relationship from her authoritarian father she is victim to abuse and ridicule and forced to run away from her family.

Naima is the protagonist of the second story. She is a successful forty-something doctor pressured into an arranged marriage with somebody she doesn't love.

Amina lives with her husband and young daughter and is the subject of horrific physical abuse from which she cannot escape.

The raw violence in 'Honey and Ashes' emphasises the repression of woman, man's attitude towards them and the desperate measures one of these women takes to try and gain control of her life.

These three completely separate stories intertwine with each other as we witness a battle between modernity and tradition. This juxtaposition between the traditional and the contemporary can perhaps be linked to the title of the film in which sweet tasting honey contrasts with the bitterness of death and ashes. The authentic music and dancing express the culture and contrast with the reality of the unhappiness and violence of a film which results in tragedy.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
From the Ashes to the Honey
zclfd3627 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Nadia Fares' "Honey and Ashes" is a controversial depiction of the female condition in contemporary North Africa. The key protagonists Leila, Amina and Naima offer up very different perspectives into what is/was predominantly a male-orientated culture, and their stories respectively portray the deeply ingrained, misogynistic values that men can still maintain.

The three stories are interwoven in that each of the women are coincidentally (directly or indirectly) acquainted. This linking of three very separate struggles highlights the underlying feminist motif in "Honey and Ashes", and the idea that women are stronger if together, in this 'rebellion' against suppression. Naima's position as a doctor, a position of great responsibility, contradicts the old-fashioned prejudice of women as being relatively powerless and insignificant, and signals hope. Such hope can be instilled in the younger generation and can inspire change, exemplified by Naima's daughter, who is offered a fresh start at life in a new school. The door to her school is opened by a mute man, which perhaps suggests that in this 'new world', men aren't as dominant as they once were, and women have their rightful place in society.

Escape is a central theme in the film, and something that each of the women long for, clearly illustrated by Leila running from the three men who presumed her to be promiscuous. She is not truly running from these men however, but from what they represent. "Honey and Ashes" is a compelling and intelligent insight into the workings of the Arab world, and hopefully has helped fuel the transition from 'the ashes', a tradition of female suppression, to 'the honey', a seemingly 'sweeter' modernity.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Raw, Real, and Sad - a Compelling Film
FafaSays28 June 2003
HONEY AND ASHES is about three women who live in a North African Islamic country. Each has a different life. Leila is a headstrong, intelligent student. Naima is a doctor with a young daughter, and Amina is a housewife also with a daughter.

Despite their differences, they have something in common. They are caught between the modern and traditional rules for a woman because they live in a patriarchal society.

Leila has to hide her feelings for her true love from her strict father; Naima's family forces her into an unwanted arranged marriage; and Amina's husband, a popular university professor, constantly abuses her.

The three storylines captivated me. It is very raw, very real, and in many ways very sad. Despite the circumstances, the film also shows the strength of women.

HONEY AND ASHES is a striking view of the lives of some women. It is a compelling film to watch.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed