Sidney Shorr: A Girl's Best Friend (TV Movie 1981) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Another perspective on "Sidney Shorr: A Girl's Best Friend"
jf_moran4919 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The TV film "Sidney Shorr: A Girl's Best Friend" definitely did mention the fact that its titled character was homosexual. It's been so long since I have seen it, only saw it when first aired on NBC, but I distinctly recall it mentioned the main character's homosexuality very briefly and, as another poster has said, it was very understated and that was the only mention of it.

But once the property was picked up by NBC, the role of the little girl's ("Patti's") mother, "Laurie," re-cast with Swoosie Kurtz for the series "Love, Sidney," the fact of its main character's sexual orientation was never again mentioned, only implied by lifestyle--i.e., living alone as platonic best friend of single mother & "father figure" to her daughter. And anyway, the sex life of "Sidney" was irrelevant to the overall theme of the continuing story, which was the relationship between "Shorr," "Laurie" and "Patti." I do recall that it was a very sweet, very well-written film, very nicely played by Tony Randall (who was always excellent & added a touch of class to whatever work in which he appeared).

I will disagree with the previous poster, "jewel," about one aspect of her/his review of this film. The overall message on the film's concluding scene was not "Sidney, alone, heartbroken, amid the dozens & dozens of pictures," but rather--Sidney, again living solitary, but warmed by the many pictures sent him by his surrogate daughter, symbolic of the fact that they had remained in contact over the intervening passage of time. And so the film ended as it began, Sidney living alone, yes, but content and happy for the fact of having had this daughter figure brought into his life. In no way did the film end on a down note--to state otherwise is to have missed the point! It's all a matter of proper perspective and context, really.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
a long-lost obscure little gem
boumboum3418 May 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This obscure little 1981 made-for-TV movie is a gem, my favorite Tony Randall movie. Sweet, gentle, warm, and poignant. Intelligently written, and really pulls at your heartstrings.

The whole movie revolves around two platonic relationships, first between Sidney and a young woman, Laura, who brings an energy and vivacity that transforms Sidney's life, then between Sidney and Laura's daughter Patty. Sidney and Patty are the heart of the movie.

Randall plays Sidney Shorr, a lonely commercial artist who lives alone in New York City, with quiet elegance and class. Kaleena Kiff plays the little girl Patty Morgan with tremendous charm and sweetness. She is adorable! Lorna Patterson plays the troubled yet vibrant young woman Sidney meets, befriends, and eventually takes into his home after she becomes pregnant with Patty. Lorna's performance takes a back seat to Tony's and Kaleena's but nevertheless does an excellent job.

Much was made later of the homosexuality of Sidney. However that was a very minor part of the actual movie, understated and subtle. Blink and you'll miss the gay reference entirely. The movie was first broadcast in 1981, an era when homosexuality was far less accepted than today. The movie handled it with sensitivity, class, and dignity. That movie marked the beginning of a sea change in attitudes towards homosexuals.

The whole movie revolves around two platonic relationships, first between Sidney and Laura, who brings an energy and vivacity that transforms Sidney's life, then between Sidney and Laura's daughter Patty. Sidney and Patty are the heart of the movie.

The movie is quiet, gentle, warm, with a very strong happy/sad quality to it, particularly at the end, a very difficult achievement. I wish this movie was better known, and I wish especially this was available on DVD (or better, blu-ray) or even VHS. I've been hoping for a DVD release for decades.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Wonderful film
Jenfranbax27 September 2005
This starts off with Tony as a lonely gentleman who has the same routine every single day. Getting some cold cuts and potato salad and eating alone in his little flat every single night. Never does it say anywhere that this is a homosexual individual. I never got that impression. In any case he meets a young lady and has her move in with him after he becomes very attached to her. She is quite young and full of energy and brings life into his household. I think....It has been awhile since this was on TV, that she becomes pregnant and he wants her to keep the baby and raise it in his place. In time she meets someone and has to say goodbye and his life goes back to the same old routine again. It was a very sad movie I thought. The spin off TV show dealt gingerly with his "homosexuality" in one episode. The show was cute although I wanted to hit the kid who sang the "We're friends forever!!" song....
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed