IMDb on iPhone and iPod touch Learn more Learn more Download from the App Store
IMDb > Bian cheng san xia (1966) > IMDb user reviews

IMDb user comments for
Bian cheng san xia (1966) More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

4 out of 6 people found the following review useful:
Another Wang Yu swordfighting classic, 21 May 2001
Author: Brian Camp from Bronx, NY

THE MAGNIFICENT TRIO (1966) is a colorful Hong Kong swordplay film that stars Jimmy Wang Yu as an ex-soldier who bravely intervenes in a dispute between villagers and a corrupt magistrate. The swordplay is abundant, but staged in the slash-and-swing style, in which the heroes kill their opponents with one slash, while they themselves suffer repeated stabbings and arrow wounds yet keep fighting. It's not terribly realistic, but is exciting and beautifully photographed at the Shaw Bros. studio. The film is often cited as a Hong Kong version of the Japanese film THREE OUTLAWS. It does indeed play like a Samurai film but is laced with the melodramatic flavor common to Hong Kong films of the time.

In the course of the 108-minute film, Wang Yu arrives in town just after the villagers kidnap the magistrate's daughter and prepare a petition for visiting Minister Yuan alleging unjust taxation and exploitation by the magistrate. A deal is made and Wang Yu returns the daughter and offers to accept the punishment that would have been dished out to the three kidnappers. The magistrate breaks his word and the daughter, who has fallen for Wang Yu, has her maid help him escape. Usually cast as a loner, Wang Yu is joined here by two allies to form the trio of the title, first by his army buddy (Cheng Lei) and later by one of the magistrate's men (Lo Lieh), who sees the rightness of the villagers' cause. Eventually the trio takes on all the magistrate's guards in an effort to get the petition to the visiting minister.

In addition to the three main actors, the cast includes familiar Shaw Bros. players such as Wu Ma, Tien Feng and Ku Feng, as well as three excellent actresses in key roles, Margaret Tu Chuan, Chin Ping and Fanny Fan. There is a very nice original music score, although there are no songs. If you're a fan of Wang Yu's other 1960s swordplay films-TWIN SWORDS, THE ASSASSIN, THE ONE-ARMED SWORDSMAN, TRAIL OF THE BROKEN BLADE, and RETURN OF THE ONE-ARMED SWORDSMAN, all made before Wang Yu became Hong Kong's first genuine kung fu star in THE Chinese BOXER-you'll like this one also. The VHS edition available in the U.S. is in Mandarin with English subtitles and cries out for letter-boxing, because the full-frame transfer cuts off the subtitles on the sides, making some dialogue difficult to decipher.

ADDENDUM: In April 2003, Celestial Pictures/IVL released a Region 3 DVD offering a restored, remastered edition of this film as part of its new line of Shaw Bros. releases. It's letter-boxed, in Mandarin, with English subtitles.

Was the above comment useful to you?

0 out of 1 people found the following review useful:
Jimmy Wang Yu shows some emotion, 10 November 2007
6/10
Author: phillip-58 from United Kingdom

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Not one of the best Shaw's productions but the Celestial DVD release is well done, though a few extras (apart from trailers) would have been nice. But always good to see Jimmy Wang Yu and Lo Lieh together and Cheng Lei has a good, if ultimately tragic, role. Heroic tragedy is a concept still alien to Hollywood (I suppose 300 comes closest) but very common in Asian films where it is considered a virtue. Anyway the fight scenes are a bit hack and slash and all done mainly with swords (no kung fu here). Jimmy Wang Yu almost shows some emotion at the end as he rides into the sunset leaving behind his love interest who for reasons not entirely clear (betraying her father I guess) has become a Buddhist Nun. A good film but not one of the best.

Was the above comment useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings External reviews Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history