This sequel to "Die Trapp Familie" tells the story of the Von Trapps after their immigration to the USA; this could have been a nice follow-up, but it seems as Wolfgang Liebeneiner did it without much interest and at least with little inspiration, but he had also to deal with a weaker script than with "Die Trapp Familie"; the producer should have used Georg Hurdalek again. The film proceeds awkwardly from one situation to the other and has little dramatic atmosphere; scene in Vermont: a walk, they find a house, "yes, we buy the house", end of scene, next scene. Again there is good music by Franz Grothe, including some music in the Gershwin idiom. Ruth Leuwerik is fine again as Maria; in the last shot she addresses (as in "Die Trapp Familie") directly the viewer this time saying "Auf Wiedersehen", probably hinting at a second sequel which luckily was never made.
5 Reviews
The singing family hit hard times
foordie17 January 1999
The saga continues with the troubled lives of the sweet family - seems the folksongs are out of step with the new rock and roll era. Sniff ! They should have stopped at the first film - the second is just too much to swallow.
Ruth LEUWERIK and her singing family in America
ZeddaZogenau28 January 2024
Sequel to the successful film with Ruth Leuwerik and Hans Holt
So now they have arrived in America! The Trapps and their many children have found shelter in the cramped Bronx. With Pastor Wasner (Josef Meinrad, 1913-1996) in tow, the singing family seeks success in performing spiritual songs by Bach and Palestrina. Of course that can't go well. Baron Trapp (Hans Holt, 1909-2001) wants to give up, although their American driver Patrick (Wolfgang Wahl, 1925-2006) encourages him. An appointment with agent Harris (Holger Hagen), who sees no future for this deadly boring family, turns into a real fiasco. Mother Trapp (Ruth Leuwerik, 1924-2016) needs to read a little more sex appeal in books. But it comes as it has to come. First, the neighbors (including Til Klokow (1900-1970) as Bronx-Lilly, who is known as the voice of Claudette Colbert (Cleopatra / It Happened One Night) and Gloria Swanson (Sunset Boulevard)) in the notorious Bronx come across the really beautiful voices of the children (Regensburger Domspatzen). And then the family gets to know a millionaire's wife from Austria (with a lot of Viennese insults: Adrienne Gessner, 1896-1987), who has a decisive influence on the music repertoire. As soon as "Oh Susanna" and in the final scene "No beautiful country in this time" are heard, the interested viewer is done for. Splendid!
Of course, from today's perspective, it all seems all too old-fashioned when the then superstar Ruth Leuwerik goes in search of more sex appeal or the old priest clings to the extended family like a burr. The exterior shots of New York convey a great feeling of authenticity, and the children (including Michael Ande and Ursula Wolff) are sooooo cute! Almost 8 million viewers wanted to see the film in West German cinemas. Two years earlier, THE TRAPP FAMILY had attracted more than 26 million viewers to the cinemas!
The director was the veteran Wolfgang Liebeneiner (1905-1987), the script was written by Herbert Reinecker. What the man has written! The busy Ilse Kubaschewski (1907-2001), who with her Gloria film distribution company was one of the most important figures in the German-speaking film industry of the 1950s and 1960s, acted as producer.
The great Ruth Leuwerik cannot be praised enough! How lucky that there was once such a big film star in the German-speaking world! If you want to see this fantastic actress in her later years, you shouldn't miss the two DERRICK episodes "An Ambush" (1978) and "The Perpetrator Sent Flowers" (1983).
Wonderfully nostalgic!
So now they have arrived in America! The Trapps and their many children have found shelter in the cramped Bronx. With Pastor Wasner (Josef Meinrad, 1913-1996) in tow, the singing family seeks success in performing spiritual songs by Bach and Palestrina. Of course that can't go well. Baron Trapp (Hans Holt, 1909-2001) wants to give up, although their American driver Patrick (Wolfgang Wahl, 1925-2006) encourages him. An appointment with agent Harris (Holger Hagen), who sees no future for this deadly boring family, turns into a real fiasco. Mother Trapp (Ruth Leuwerik, 1924-2016) needs to read a little more sex appeal in books. But it comes as it has to come. First, the neighbors (including Til Klokow (1900-1970) as Bronx-Lilly, who is known as the voice of Claudette Colbert (Cleopatra / It Happened One Night) and Gloria Swanson (Sunset Boulevard)) in the notorious Bronx come across the really beautiful voices of the children (Regensburger Domspatzen). And then the family gets to know a millionaire's wife from Austria (with a lot of Viennese insults: Adrienne Gessner, 1896-1987), who has a decisive influence on the music repertoire. As soon as "Oh Susanna" and in the final scene "No beautiful country in this time" are heard, the interested viewer is done for. Splendid!
Of course, from today's perspective, it all seems all too old-fashioned when the then superstar Ruth Leuwerik goes in search of more sex appeal or the old priest clings to the extended family like a burr. The exterior shots of New York convey a great feeling of authenticity, and the children (including Michael Ande and Ursula Wolff) are sooooo cute! Almost 8 million viewers wanted to see the film in West German cinemas. Two years earlier, THE TRAPP FAMILY had attracted more than 26 million viewers to the cinemas!
The director was the veteran Wolfgang Liebeneiner (1905-1987), the script was written by Herbert Reinecker. What the man has written! The busy Ilse Kubaschewski (1907-2001), who with her Gloria film distribution company was one of the most important figures in the German-speaking film industry of the 1950s and 1960s, acted as producer.
The great Ruth Leuwerik cannot be praised enough! How lucky that there was once such a big film star in the German-speaking world! If you want to see this fantastic actress in her later years, you shouldn't miss the two DERRICK episodes "An Ambush" (1978) and "The Perpetrator Sent Flowers" (1983).
Wonderfully nostalgic!
Neither bad nor good, but surely above average
MauriceDeSaxe28 July 2004
It came as no surprise to anyone that all involved should choose to follow 'Die Trapp Familie', one of the most successful German films of the 50's, with a sequel. The result was 'Die Trapp Familie in Amerika' and it literally began where the earlier film left off.
With Ruth Leuwerik reprising her formidable performance as Baronin von Trapp, the producers clearly hoped their subject's on-going story would help swell the studio's coffers once more - it did! Lavishly produced, director W. Liebeneiner turned every single one of the film's galloping clichés into gold. However, the red meat of the Trapp-saga had already been devoured by audiences in Part One - and all that was left second time around were scraps of plot. Spicing it up and helping to make the most of the least were the gorgeous gowns worn by Miss Leuwerik, who looked a treat!
With Ruth Leuwerik reprising her formidable performance as Baronin von Trapp, the producers clearly hoped their subject's on-going story would help swell the studio's coffers once more - it did! Lavishly produced, director W. Liebeneiner turned every single one of the film's galloping clichés into gold. However, the red meat of the Trapp-saga had already been devoured by audiences in Part One - and all that was left second time around were scraps of plot. Spicing it up and helping to make the most of the least were the gorgeous gowns worn by Miss Leuwerik, who looked a treat!
Seen on German TV
showen23 April 2006
I've seen this film on German TV. The German TV guide gives it a "thumbs down". But it's fun to compare this story with what one sees in "Sound of Music", and the shots of 1950s New York City are great. The musical leader of the Trapp Family Singers is a priest. He tries to get the group gigs singing nothing but church music, but of course it doesn't work. If I recall correctly, an agent hears the family singing folk music by chance, and hires them. In both this film and the film that preceded it, the actors sing the same music that the Von Trapp Family sang, not Rodgers and Hammerstein. I don't know if this is available with English subtitles.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
