Apache Warrior (1957) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"The only man who can catch an Apache is another Apache."
classicsoncall17 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
An opening title card stated that this was a true story, but I would certainly hedge my bets on that score. The only accurate take away from the film is the fact that Katawan/Apache Kid (Keith Larsen) once served as a scout in the U.S. Army and for some reason turned renegade against the white man. The movie implies that this occurred after killing his Apache enemy Chato (George Keymas), who earlier had murdered Katawan's brother Chikisin. It certainly looked like self defense in the film, but Katawan refused to speak up for himself and was about to be sent to Yuma Territorial Prison for murder. Escaping his Army guards, he leaves his former partner Ben Ziegler (Jim Davis) for dead, but you'll do a double take when that scene occurs. To make sure Ziegler is dead, Apache Mahteen shoots him after Katawan fires wide feigning a killing shot. Ziegler does a half sit up to see what's going on, and at the same time, Mahteen looks in his direction. Proper editing could have prevented the contradictory looking scene, but instead, the Indians simply rode away.

The movie leaves it entirely unclear as to when the Apache Kid went on his murderous rampage across the Southwest. Presumably it was after Ziegler helped him escape bounty hunters at the end of the picture, but that would have left out a major portion of the Kid's history. I was intrigued enough by this to search out the episode dealing with the Apache Kid on my DVD set of 'Stories Of The Century', with episodes from the 1954 TV series. I wasn't too surprised that the stories didn't match up very closely, except for the basic outline of Apache Kid as an Army scout who went bad. No reason given for the turn, but the episode offered a colorful description of the Kid as 'a stalking werewolf with a blood lust'. His rampage began after escaping from his Yuma bound guards, and over the next few months went on a killing spree totaling over a hundred whites and red men. Although 'Stories Of The Century' purports to be based on actual newspaper accounts of the Old West, the ending of this particular story ends ambiguously as well, with the only three eyewitnesses to Apache Kid's death agreeing to a cover up. So how did they make the story?

Ultimately, "Apache Warrior" is merely an OK Western, with not as much action and suspense that one might expect. You'll probably wonder about that ending too; all those rifle rounds flying and no one getting hit. It almost seemed gratuitous that one of the bounty hunters got shot in the finale. I would like to have heard actor Jim Davis's take on the Apache Kid saga, oddly, he appeared in both the movie and as the lead character, railroad detective Matt Clark, in 'Stories Of The Century'.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Better to ride 2 horses than a dead horse"
weezeralfalfa8 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
The best thing about this B&W 'B' western is the screenplay, which centers around the Apache warrior Katawan(The Apache Kid), and his rather ambiguous status as an Apache paid by the US army to capture dead or alive troublesome Apache renegades. He continues to wear the standard Apache clothing which contributes to the perception of his ambiguous status., and occasionally makes it more difficult to tell him from other Apache.....Near the beginning, Katawan shoots dead a renegade who tried to escape from him and his white friend Ben Zieglar, The 3 others, including leader Marteen, are brought into the fort for trial and sentencing. A little while later, Chato kills Katawan's brother with a knife in the back. The slow-speaking old chief Nantan confirms that , according to Apache custom, Katawan must kill Chato, so that the soul of the murdered can be released from the earth. This is made more dangerous by the fact that Chato is intent on killing Katawan, as well, and in fact jumps Katawan from a rock. They have a knife fight, and Chato is killed. Ben and a soldier had been trailing Katawan and took him into custody, taking him to the fort. The Major sentenced him to 7 years in the territorial prison at Yuma, considering this a light sentence. Katawan and Chief Nantan argue that he was obligated by Apache custom to kill Chato. The Major argued that Katawan had accepted a position in white society, thus white law superseded Apache custom in his case. Katawan escapes serving this sentence by joining with Marteen and 2 others in jumping the guards while being transported to prison. Katawan nearly drowns Ben, who was also accompanying the wagon. He didn't want Ben to die, so feigned shooting Ben in the head to make sure he was dead.... Now, the question is: can Katawan be trusted as a comrade to the others. He says he doesn't have a choice. Marteen says he will be leader of the group. Eventually, he and Katawan have a knife fight. The others side with Marteen and hit Katawan until he is unconscious, then leave him. Marteen and compatriots go on a white man killing spree. The Major decides the best chance of capturing Marteen and Katawan is to contract with bounty hunters. However, an army patrol gets to Marteen first....Ben goes looking for Katawan to kill him for almost drowning him. He finds him, with his girlfriend , Liwana. See the movie(at You Tube) for the climax and rather unsatisfying ending....The dialogue involving the Apache is leaden, as according to Hollywood tradition, Keith Larsen, as Katawan , is not charismatic, nor is Rodolfo Acosta as Marteen. John Miljan is appropriately stoic as the wise old chief. Eugenia Paul serves as the demure Liwana, who pops up every now and then as Katawan's woman. She's concerned about whether they will live as Apache or as whites. She sites several reasons why she is envious of white women. Jim Davis plays the conflicted Ben Zeiglar, while Damian O'Flynn makes a good Major. See it on YouTube
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The white and Apache worlds
bkoganbing15 April 2020
Keith Larsen recently graduated from the Brave Eagle series is the lead in this low budget film about a man trying most unsuccessfully to live in both the white and Apache worlds.

Jim Davis plays white army scout who is Larsen's only friend and later has to hunt him. Apache law allows for honor killing, but that doesn't fly in the world. You won't blame Larsen when you see the reason.

The film is a no frills B film. But the players are fine and so is their direction. The last scene is a shoot out with bounty hunters and his well staged.

Western fans should give this one a look.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Believe you me, "3" is a generous mark!
JohnHowardReid11 June 2017
Regal Films, released by 20th Century-Fox, August 1957 (U.S.A.), October 1957 (U.K.), 12th December 1957 (Australia). 6,595 feet. 73 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: After helping the U.S. army round up his Indian "brothers" after the defeat of Geronimo, the Apache Kid turns renegade when an actual brother is murdered.

COMMENT: Dreary, slow-moving western, its banal, cliché-ridden script directed with disappointing spiritlessness by Elmo Williams. Maybe if this thing had been directed by some hack like Edward L. Cahn it would have received a slightly higher rating — though even by Mr. Cahn's humble standards it is way below average — but we expect much more from a talent of Mr. Williams' caliber. What little action there is in the film is tame in the extreme. For the rest of the time we are forced to listen to one of the least interesting casts on record talking their fool heads off. Miss Paul is a charmless heroine and Mr. Miljan a particularly corny Indian, while the one capable player in the cast, Mr. Acosta, has but a minuscule role.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good western, fine acting, lotsa action.
bux23 October 1998
Loosely based on the legend of the Apache Kid, this is a fine low budget entry. Larson(he was Brave Eagle in the TV series) is great as the warrior that is double crossed by the army he aided in bringing in Geronimo. "Big' Jim Davis does well in a role obviously patterned after scout Al Seiber. Considering the cast and crew, this one bears the mark of something Robert L. Lippert had his hand in, as an executive at Fox.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A big lost chance to offer something great
searchanddestroy-18 February 2024
The basic plot excited me so much before watching it, a renegade Indian in charge to capture another Indian, a big chief, Geronimo himself. So exciting, very unusual. It offered many opportunities to bring something never seen before, especially for a fifties western. But, first, the main "uncomfortable" element here is that this movie seems available ONLY in f...pan and scan, which is absolutely unbearable, and second, the ending is so lousy, so unsatisfactory. I was literally smashed by this finale. For the rest, it is good, never boring, with an excellent and convincing Keith Larsen. No, such a waste this western, I prefer forget it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed