Vesta Tilley was still a household word back in 2006 when I first saw this movie on TV. Alas, that fame has not survived until today, but it's still pretty good going for someone who retired from the music hall circuit way back in 1919. Nonetheless, although sumptuously photographed in pleasing Eastman Colour (sic), the film is a bit disappointing. True, it does have atmosphere and whenever it focuses on the stage, it's lively and exciting. On the other hand, the back-stage story, although no doubt at least partly true, is dull and clichéd. And Compton Bennett's leaden direction certainly does not help. Fortunately, the musical highlights are put across with considerable gusto. It was a real stroke of genius by producers Gerald Thomas and Peter Rogers to have Miss Kirkwood's songs backed up not by some cheesy little band of a dozen or so instruments but with the astonishing expertise of the world-famous concert orchestra, Sinfonia of London!
8 Reviews
Strike a light, Vesta!
F Gwynplaine MacIntyre2 December 2005
I've never understood the appeal of the male impersonator: the actress who pretends to be a boy or a man. The only context in which this makes sense to me is the British panto, in which the 'principal boy' is played by an actress whose male costume of tight-fitting breeches actually emphasises (rather than conceals) her very female attributes. I also understand that certain 'trouser roles' in classical opera are easier for the female voice to perform than the male. But, as for the actresses who make a speciality of genuinely trying to pass as male ... what's the point?
Yet for some reason, from the late Victorian era up until the 1930s, male impersonators were hugely popular in Britain. Ronnie Barker's cheeky anthology 'Sauce' reprints a piece of Victorian doggerel about two brothers who did an act in the variety halls: realising that sister acts were more popular than brother acts, they billed themselves as women but appeared onstage in masculine dress ... and became far more successful as 'male impersonators' than they would have been as male performers.
One of the most popular and successful male impersonators was Vesta Tilley (1864-1952). She had a repertoire of male characters, most notably Burlington Bertie (a homeless man who sleeps in the Burlington Arcade but boasts about his social contacts). Dressed as a sailor, she performed 'Jolly Good Luck to the Girl Who Loves a Sailor'. As a roguish womaniser, she sang 'I'm Following in Father's Footsteps, I'm Following Me Dear Old Dad'. Her sentimental ballad was 'Sweetheart May'. As Tilley sang all of her songs in the contralto-soprano range, one wonders why she bothered with the male disguises.
'After the Ball' (named for another of her song hits) is ostensibly Tilley's life story, filmed on a painfully low budget. All the usual showbiz clichés are here. The most interesting scenes are Tilley's interactions with various British and American theatrical figures. In New York City, she works for impresarios Tony Pastor and Oscar Hammerstein: the latter is not the lyricist, but his namesake grandfather. Sadly, this film doesn't even make a token attempt to depict these men accurately. Pastor was massively fat, and Hammerstein (the original) had an elaborate beard: you'd never know it from the actors on offer here.
I was intrigued to see George M Cohan's name in the cast list of this movie. Apparently, Tilley actually performed in a stage comedy with Cohan at least once. Here, Cohan is played brashly by obscure actor Mark Baker. It's disappointing that Cohan (or, rather, Baker as Cohan) never once cuts loose with some 'Yankee Doodle Dandy' song-and-dancing here. More regrettable is the fact that Baker hasn't got even a fraction of the dynamic presence of Cohan himself, nor of James Cagney nor Joel Grey: two performers who have played Cohan far more memorably than Baker does here.
The romantic male lead is essayed by Laurence Harvey, as the titled Englishman who becomes Vesta's match. Whenever you see the words 'romantic lead' and 'Laurence Harvey' in the same sentence, you know something's wrong. Harvey is so cold and unemotional here, he seems to be practising for his role as the brainwashed zombie in 'The Manchurian Candidate'.
In the central role as Vesta Tilley, Pat Kirkwood is attractive and personable but utterly fails to convince me that she was one of the leading stage performers of the early twentieth century. Kirkwood's forays into male garb are embarrassing; she seems to be eager to convince us that she really *isn't* a man. More intriguing, in her brief appearance, is child actress Margaret Sawyer playing Tilley as a child. I have a deep passion for the history of the British entertainment industry during precisely the time period depicted in this movie, yet 'After the Ball' largely fails to capture the spark and excitement of that era. The very poor art direction doesn't help. I'll generously rate this movie 6 out of 10.
Yet for some reason, from the late Victorian era up until the 1930s, male impersonators were hugely popular in Britain. Ronnie Barker's cheeky anthology 'Sauce' reprints a piece of Victorian doggerel about two brothers who did an act in the variety halls: realising that sister acts were more popular than brother acts, they billed themselves as women but appeared onstage in masculine dress ... and became far more successful as 'male impersonators' than they would have been as male performers.
One of the most popular and successful male impersonators was Vesta Tilley (1864-1952). She had a repertoire of male characters, most notably Burlington Bertie (a homeless man who sleeps in the Burlington Arcade but boasts about his social contacts). Dressed as a sailor, she performed 'Jolly Good Luck to the Girl Who Loves a Sailor'. As a roguish womaniser, she sang 'I'm Following in Father's Footsteps, I'm Following Me Dear Old Dad'. Her sentimental ballad was 'Sweetheart May'. As Tilley sang all of her songs in the contralto-soprano range, one wonders why she bothered with the male disguises.
'After the Ball' (named for another of her song hits) is ostensibly Tilley's life story, filmed on a painfully low budget. All the usual showbiz clichés are here. The most interesting scenes are Tilley's interactions with various British and American theatrical figures. In New York City, she works for impresarios Tony Pastor and Oscar Hammerstein: the latter is not the lyricist, but his namesake grandfather. Sadly, this film doesn't even make a token attempt to depict these men accurately. Pastor was massively fat, and Hammerstein (the original) had an elaborate beard: you'd never know it from the actors on offer here.
I was intrigued to see George M Cohan's name in the cast list of this movie. Apparently, Tilley actually performed in a stage comedy with Cohan at least once. Here, Cohan is played brashly by obscure actor Mark Baker. It's disappointing that Cohan (or, rather, Baker as Cohan) never once cuts loose with some 'Yankee Doodle Dandy' song-and-dancing here. More regrettable is the fact that Baker hasn't got even a fraction of the dynamic presence of Cohan himself, nor of James Cagney nor Joel Grey: two performers who have played Cohan far more memorably than Baker does here.
The romantic male lead is essayed by Laurence Harvey, as the titled Englishman who becomes Vesta's match. Whenever you see the words 'romantic lead' and 'Laurence Harvey' in the same sentence, you know something's wrong. Harvey is so cold and unemotional here, he seems to be practising for his role as the brainwashed zombie in 'The Manchurian Candidate'.
In the central role as Vesta Tilley, Pat Kirkwood is attractive and personable but utterly fails to convince me that she was one of the leading stage performers of the early twentieth century. Kirkwood's forays into male garb are embarrassing; she seems to be eager to convince us that she really *isn't* a man. More intriguing, in her brief appearance, is child actress Margaret Sawyer playing Tilley as a child. I have a deep passion for the history of the British entertainment industry during precisely the time period depicted in this movie, yet 'After the Ball' largely fails to capture the spark and excitement of that era. The very poor art direction doesn't help. I'll generously rate this movie 6 out of 10.
Something For The Boys
writers_reign7 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
As it turns out there are TWO male impersonators in this film, Pat Kirkwood and Laurence Harvet and neither is wholly convincing. The main selling point for me was a screenplay by Hubert Gregg who was, of course, married for a time to Pat Kirkwood, but for a writer of Gregg's calibre the screenplay is lacklustre at best. As was his wont Harvey managed yet again to snatch a suet pudding from the jaws of a soufflé and Kirkwood isn't far behind performing Tilley's signature songs as if immersed Houdini-like in a large tank of water. It's difficult to envisage this whole project conceived as anything other than a tax loss.
A Sensation in Trousers
richardchatten25 October 2019
When this film was made Vesta Tilly had only died five years ago, and Leonard Sachs (who appears in a small part) had already been playing the verbose chairman on TV in 'The Good Old Days' for four. So the time was ripe for this ambitious production in colour by Peter Rogers just before he hit it rich with the 'Carry On' films.
Now that so few men bother to wear collars and ties, music hall acts like Vesta Tilley's look even more archaic that they did at the turn of the last century, when Tilly instructs husband-to-be Walter de Frece "You really must learn how to tie a tie!"
Most of the film is given over to Pat Kirkwood recreating Ms Tilly's musical numbers, looking most fetching in a variety of formal outfits including Great War khaki. (Tilly's repertoire had in fact originally also included principal boys; but sadly we never see Kirkwood in fishnets.)
Laurence Harvey is as usual completely out of his depth as a romantic leading man.
Now that so few men bother to wear collars and ties, music hall acts like Vesta Tilley's look even more archaic that they did at the turn of the last century, when Tilly instructs husband-to-be Walter de Frece "You really must learn how to tie a tie!"
Most of the film is given over to Pat Kirkwood recreating Ms Tilly's musical numbers, looking most fetching in a variety of formal outfits including Great War khaki. (Tilly's repertoire had in fact originally also included principal boys; but sadly we never see Kirkwood in fishnets.)
Laurence Harvey is as usual completely out of his depth as a romantic leading man.
The British music hall gives a colorful, sunny forecast, with occasional patches of fog.
mark.waltz28 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
There's something about this musical biography of Vesta Tilley (my intro to her) that reminds me of the slew of period "biography" musicals of the mid 40's, occasionally done into the early 50's, and pretty old fashioned, especially when compared to the big movie musicals of hit Broadway shows. With musicals somewhat on the wane in the late 50's, this seems doubly out of date, even though it is easy going, light hearted entertainment, with a pretty leading lady (Pat Kirkwood) and a slew of music hall numbers I've never heard of, all presented in gorgeous color loaded with pastels.
The basic story surround the rise to fame of Tilley, both in London and New York, and her romance with upperclass gentleman Laurence Harvey which resulted in marriage and her leaving the business. The title song, a huge standard, is a surprise for people unaware that it was not written for "Show Boat". Kirkwood, whose act mainly consisted of her performing in men's clothes, has a speaking reminiscent of Julie Andrews, so hearing her speaking brings on visions of Julie in "Victor/Victoria". Nothing groundbreaking about this film, but Kirkwood's charm makes it refreshing with Harvey not really getting anything outstanding to do but looking very handsome.
The basic story surround the rise to fame of Tilley, both in London and New York, and her romance with upperclass gentleman Laurence Harvey which resulted in marriage and her leaving the business. The title song, a huge standard, is a surprise for people unaware that it was not written for "Show Boat". Kirkwood, whose act mainly consisted of her performing in men's clothes, has a speaking reminiscent of Julie Andrews, so hearing her speaking brings on visions of Julie in "Victor/Victoria". Nothing groundbreaking about this film, but Kirkwood's charm makes it refreshing with Harvey not really getting anything outstanding to do but looking very handsome.
After the Ball review
JoeytheBrit14 May 2020
Vesta Tilly certainly lived a happy and successful life, with a happy marriage and no major tragedy to speak of. Unfortunately, that kind of life doesn't exactly make riveting entertainment. The most striking aspect of After the Ball is the way that the characters don't age at all from 1882 to 1916, but then suddenly get old very quickly. Pat Kirkwood gives a likeable performance as Tilly, but a young Laurence Harvey is miscast as her husband and manager.
Clichés musical with underwhelming performances
malcolmgsw10 July 2017
This film was made when music hall was on its last legs.The Ginsburg Park Empire would close the following year and there would be nothing left.Vests Tilley was a male impersonator,but you would not have known it from this film.I remember seeing Hefty King who was an excellent performer.Pat Kirkwood was simply not up to the task.She wasn't really a film actress and didn't have another starring opportunity.Laurence Harvey appears in a number of unconvinced wigs under which he gives an unconvincing performance.So films,which with radio contributed to the demise of the music hall really sticks the knife in with this film.
I absolutely LOVED this movie!
overseer-31 February 2018
What sourpusses among the other reviewers for this lovely film, covering the British hall music era from 1880's to after the WW1 era, and in particular one very famous male impersonator singer, dancer entertainer named Vesta Tilly. I thought Pat Kirkwood's Vesta Tilly was WONDERFUL! Even inspirational. I was happy the movie didn't shortchange scenes of actual stage performances. For the first time I actually enjoyed a performance by Laurence Harvey as Vesta's husband and manager, for once he wasn't cold and taciturn in a role but warm, smiling, supportive and loving. He should have played more characters like this one! The old songs were great to hear and if you flip on subtitles you can sing along with the original lyrics to the great old tunes. This movie was made in the 1950's so there would be people in their 70's or older still alive who would have remembered Vesta and her popularity on the English music hall stages of the turn of that century. I was left with a warm glow watching this movie. You can see it for free with an Amazon Prime membership streaming if you have a ROKU or similar device. Take yourself out of the harsh modern era and go back to a time when entertainment was more wholesome and enjoyable and just plain fun.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
