Uma (1941) Poster

(1941)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A Girl And Her Horse
boblipton8 March 2021
Hideko Takamine's poor farming family boards a mare for the winter. Their payment will be the foal it is carrying. Her father falls ill, her mother is a judgmental and autocratic shrew, and her brothers are of no help, so it is up to Miss Takamine to take care of the mare. When the colt is born, Miss Takamine falls in love with it.

This movie is famous for being Kurosawa's first as a director.... sort of. He co-wrote the script with Kajirô Yamamoto, was credited as Assistant Director, and directed much of it, as Yamamoto was busy with another project. Looking at it, it looks more like Yamamoto's work. Thats hardly surprising. Two thirds of Kurosawa's movie as an assistant director were under Yamamoto, and while Kurosawa's themes would change, he would carry on the habit of well-written characters that show here, even in the smaller roles.

There are some fine outdoor scenes, both in the snow and the glory of a cherry-blossom spring, but the emphasis is always on Miss Takamine, who is a stubborn character, searching for something to love.

It's hard to comment meaningfully on this moment; both the star and the AD loom too large in their later work, and this obscures any attempt to define it, both in itself, as a well-written, directed, and acted drama, and in the bodies of their works; they would change and become more definite later. It's best, then, to enjoy it for what it is: a pleasant and sentimental story about a girl and her horse.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Akira Kurosawa's (co-) directing debut.
morrison-dylan-fan28 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
One of the most generous presents I've ever received from a friend, is a copy of the now-deleted Criterion AK:25 Akira Kurosawa DVD set,which I've been wanting to dive into. With the set sitting on the shelf looking at me,I was excited to recently find English subtitles for his debut (not in the Criterion set), which led to me finally discovering where it all began for Kurosawa.

View on the film:

Moving on up from being an assistant director after original co-writer/ director Kajiro Yamamoto quit the project, editor/co-writer/directing auteur Akira Kurosawa makes his mark with motifs which would be expanded upon in his solo directing credits, (with the English title for this film being "Horse",a animal that would play a part in his future credits) most prominently in the snowstorm-swept surroundings of the Onoda farm heightening the rustic Melodrama atmosphere, and low-slinging wipes closing in on the tension between the Onoda family members over keeping the horse.

Galloping onto the screen with a opening propaganda message about the army needing strong horses for the war, the screenplay by Kurosawa & Yamamoto features a surprising amount of underhanded criticism of the military, via the industrialized army treating the handing out of cash to the poor pre-industrial farming Onoda family with the same detached casualness that the army treat cattle with.

Breaking the Melodrama with a mesmerizing pose in sadness as the horse fades into the distance, Hideko Takamine gives a wonderful performance as Ine, tugging at the heartstrings with a wide-eyed innocent love for the horse.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Sentimental story
Leofwine_draca29 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A film that helped launched Akira Kurosawa's career as director in his own right. He did a lot of behind the scenes stuff here and essentially helped out the film's proper director by completing his movie for him. It's a rather dated affair, a bit pedestrian and overlong, but it does tell an effectively sentimental story about a young woman and her loving relationship with a foal that comes into her care. Some satire of the Japanese military mindset is added to the mix.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed