Tanks a Million (1941) User Reviews

James Gleason at his best

[mlevans · 7/10 · 20 December 2005]

This cute little pre-war comedy is typical fare for the era. Some nice performances make it a nice little catch for fans of immediate pre-war and wartime comedies. I found it by seeing it on James Gleason's filmography. The fine old character actor turns in one of his better performances as Col. "Spitfire" Barkley. Gleason would later gain notoriety for playing William Bendix's father-in-law in the movie version of Life of Riley and for supporting roles in films such as The Night of the Hunter.

I wasn't familiar with William Tracy, but he impressed me as the lead, "Dodo" Doubleday, a railroad information specialist, turned solider, with a photographic memory and a naïve inability to discern when his knowledge isn't wanted. Joe Sawyer is also amusing as the befuddled Sergeant Ames.

Tanks A Million was surprisingly nominated for an Oscar – for best musical score. I wouldn't have expected it to be nominated for any – although Gleason conceivably could have been in the running for best supporting actor in a comedy. Still, for clean, good old-fashioned fun, this is still a nice little movie.

Tanks Hal Roach

[bkoganbing · 6/10 · 15 February 2008]

Tanks a Million was the first of a series of films that starred William Tracy as an ingenuous army recruit with a knack of falling into good luck that is drives old time sergeant Joe Sawyer to his wit's end. I've never seen any of these films before I hope the others are as funny.

James Gleason is also along for the ride in this series as the cantankerous commanding officer of the post. As always Gleason is wonderful.

The gimmick in this film is that William Tracy as 'Dodo' Doubleday has a photographic memory and he's memorized the Army's book of rules. He's not brilliant, he's a milder version of an idiot savant, possibly Dustin Hoffman could play him if they ever wanted to make an updated version of these films. He arrives at the fort a young draftee and his knowledge of the Army manual gets him made a sergeant in one day which Sawyer took 10 years to learn.

Film fans might better remember Tracy as Misto from the Brother Rat films and as another ingenuous recruit in To The Shores of Tripoli. Tracy apparently had these characters down pat.

Hal Roach produced these films, cheaply made of course, but with some good comedy writing in them and good performances by some fine character actors.

A quick dose of good period comedy.

[mkilmer · 7/10 · 8 January 2007]

The movie starts with Bill Tracy as Dodo Doubleday, proving his incredible memory on a radio talk show. He joins the army after memorizing the regulations, which gets him quickly promoted to sergeant. His youth and inexperience bothers the other NCO's, namely Sgt. Ames (Joe Sawyer), who spends the movie trying to get Doubleday in trouble. But because of is inherent honesty and cleverness, Doubleday is able to bumble through the requisite series of mishaps and inspire loyalty in what looked to be a renegade unit. It's a fun film with good gags and good jokes, and my hat is off to James Gleason for his role as Col. Barkley.

Did I mention the series of mishaps? Or the girl (Elyse Knox)? For 50 minutes, TANKS A MILLION is an good dose of period comedy which holds up very well.

William Tracy scores as information specialist with photographic memory...

[Doylenf · 6/10 · 2 January 2007]

Typical '40s-era service comedy in the Private Hargrove tradition with WILLIAM TRACY starring as a naive information specialist who drives his Army pals crazy with his inability to perceive when his fund of information is unwanted. JOE SAWYER is the gruff and tough Sgt. Ames that he drives up a wall in some amusing incidents as Ames tries to discipline the troops and Tracy is made Sgt. Dodo Doubleday on the basis of his total recall of army regulations.

Quite a few recognizable names in the supporting cast. NOAH BEERY, JR. and FRANK FAYLEN are amusing as army recruits (draftees) and DOUGLAS FOWLEY can be seen as an irate officer inspecting the troops.

JAMES GLEASON is the new post commander, but he doesn't arrive until the last twenty minutes of the film. Before that, it's Sawyer, Tracy and Fowler who get most of the laughs.

Summing up: Trivial bit of service humor, but strictly a B-film programmer of the low-budget kind.

Fun WWII camp

[16mm-Andy · 6/10 · 15 December 2002]

This is the first movie in the Sgt Doubleday series, I think seven were made. This movie was made before U.S. involvement in WW II, but after it was becoming obvious we would get involved. This is a fun little bit of fluff with out to much plot.

O.K. Here comes some of the plot, so read on at your own risk! Doubleday (William Tracy) is a drafted and and is enthusiastic about becoming a member of the Army. He remembers every thing he reads, so he get a hold of some military manuals, reads them and "knows" every thing about the army. So in no time he is off to NCO training to become a Sargent. This drives Sgt Ames (Joe Sawyer) crazy. All this takes about the first ten minutes of the movie. The rest of the movie is Sgt Ames trying to catch Sgt Doubleday messing up, and Doubleday coming out smelling like a rose.

One other thing the actor James Gleason is not the actor Jackie Gleason of "The Honey Mooners" fame.

Some laugh out loud scenes

[Paularoc · 7/10 · 16 April 2012]

A train station information clerk (Tracy) who reads all the time and has a photographic memory is drafted into the army and sent to the dusty Camp Carver. Because he knows virtually all of the regulations and procedures, he is quickly promoted to Sergeant and is put in charge of the men he was drafted with. A sincere, well-meaning know it all, he irritates all those around him including his previous drill Sergeant Ames (Sawyer), who tries to get Tracy's character Dodo Doubleday in trouble but always fails in doing so. Doubleday gives a rousing speech nationally broadcast on radio, and because he is in the uniform of the camp's Commanding Officer (played by Gleason), all assume that it is actually the CO. The speech was such a success that Doubleday now has the CO's full support (much to Sergeant Ames' chagrin). Yes; the plot is as ridiculous as it sounds. The movie is, however very entertaining and so silly, it's fun. It was particularly nice to see so many favorite character actors, especially James Gleason. I had never heard of William Tracy but he did have a certain flair. This little movie is better than most sitcom episodes shown on television today.

Inoculation.

[rmax304823 · 6/10 · 21 May 2016]

In 1940, with war inevitable, the mass media were inoculating the public bit by bit, so that when the contest finally came, everyone had been more or less prepared for it. It's as if the world news had been a draft notice and the movies were providing the basic training.

This is a training camp comedy, about as sophisticated as its title, "Tanks a Million." It's fast, predictable, good-natured, and corny beyond imagining. I kind of liked it. Every mind needs respite.

William Tracy is the earnest young draftee with a photographic memory. He's immediately promoted to top sergeant, much to the chagrin of buck sergeant Joe Sawyer, who has put in fourteen years to Tracy's fourteen hours. The other men in the company don't like it either. Who wants a rate buster? Nevertheless, the unprepossessing Tracy may look like an invertebrate but at heart he's a hard charger, gung ho, frightened but stalwart. Oh, he brings the men into shape alright, after a couple of trials.

It won't challenge you, and there are times when an unchallenging piece of fluff is nice.

Two different army men run into hornet's nests, with different results.

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 4 May 2015]

When a private (Joe Sawyer) with an incredible memory for detail is quickly promoted to sergeant, his former drill instructor (William Tracy) is instantly incensed. Sawyer could run into a hornet's nest and only be handed a bottle of honey, while the hornets would spill the honey on Tracy so he would be attacked by a bear. That is the basic premise of a series of streamlined "B" features produced by Hal Roach that always had them at odds even though Tracy would often pretend to be Sawyer's pal in order to get something out of them. The first of the series is a hysterically funny farce that shows Sawyer on a quiz show before heading off to basic training where he instantly impresses the commanding officer with his memorization of an army guide. This sets up an instant one-sided rivalry from Tracy towards Sawyer, and when a new commanding officer (James Gleason) arrives, Tracy utilizes this as a ploy to get Sawyer in trouble by arranging for him to become Gleason's orderly. But when you've got an invisible angel on your shoulder like Sawyer does, it's obvious that Tracy's plotting will simply blow up in his face.

At under an hour, this fast-moving comedy is extremely amusing even if it doesn't represent a realistic military life. Still, it's hysterical to watch the unaware Sawyer getting the best of Tracy's scheming against him, resulting only in his rising higher than the basically dumb Tracy could hope to imagine. There's a recurring joke of a frustrated Tracy running smack into his commanding officer, usually after getting brief satisfaction of seeing Sawyer about to fail but due to a last second savior coming out of it looking even better than before. At first, the recruits under Sawyer's command seem to be against him as well, but after quick thinking saves them from the guardhouse, they change their loyalty, frustrating Tracy even more. That makes this payback towards Tracy even more delicious because the naive Sawyer wins simply out of luck than the type of ruthlessness which Tracy utilizes against him and makes him the type of hero you can truly root for.

While there's a bit of a romantic plot line here (with pretty Elyse Knox), the focus is on army life, and that suits the story just fine. When the irascible Gleason comes in half way through the film, Tracy's plotting seems to take an extremely mean-spirited turn, but by this time, you know that it's all gonna go in the opposite direction of what he wants to happen. Sawyer risks court martial when he accidentally ends up in Gleason's uniform and because of a misunderstanding ends up giving a speech which Gleason was meant to give. The actors play well off of each other, and even if Tracy is a bit too glad in his over-the-top meanness, it wins him more laughs than hisses, because it's just too fun to watch it all come back at him.

Great World War II Period Humor; largely forgotten Today, except for Turner Classic Movies! THANX, Teddy boy!

[redryan64 · 10/10 · 12 April 2008]

By the mid 1930's things at Hal Roach Studios were in a great state of unrest. The Company, which had made its major portion of Bread and Butter with the likes of Harold Lloyd, Laurel & Hardy, Snub Pollard, Will Rogers, Thelma Todd, Charley Chase, Zasu Pitts, Patsy Kelly, Edgar Kennedy, Max Davidson and OUR GANG. The format mainly employed with these Comedy Stars was that of the Short Subject. They were displayed to their best advantage in the 2 Reeler.

With 1935's THICKER THAN WATER, Laurel & Hardy had done their last Short; thereafter sticking strictly to Features. After 1936's output was all harvested and in the 'Old Barn'. Charley Chase left the Roach Lot for Jules White's Short Subjects Unit at Columbia Pictures; where he would Star in 2 reelers as well as serving as Director on Short Subjects starring the likes of Moe Howard, Larry Fine and Curly Howard.

This left Roach's Shorts Department all to Director Robert McGowan and his pet project, OUR GANG (aka THE LITTLE RASCALS). Even they were eventually sold-off to MGM during the World War II years.* MR. Roach had another innovation that he was rapidly implementing. That was the "Streamliner"; being a short Feature of about 50 minutes in length, which were designed to be the supporting film in ever more popular Double Feature. In addition to some of the fine titles of truly 1st Class Movies like TOPPER (1937), OF MICE AND MEN (1939) and ONE MILLION B.C. (1940) he gave us these sort of half cast 'B' Movie called 'Streamliner'.

Following the legislation creating our first Peacetime Draft in 1940, the Nation's thoughts were doubtless preoccupied with the War already raging in Europe, Northern Africa and East Asia. This War phobia was a natural cause of our collect concerns; so logically it was conversely a great subject matter for creating laughter and consequently releasing a lot of pent up fears and tension. In short order we saw the likes of Abbott & Costello in BUCK PRIVATES (Universal, 1941), GREAT GUNS (20th Century-Fox, 1941) with Laurel & Hardy and TRAMP, TRAMP, TRAMP (Columbia, 1942) with Jack Durant and a young Jackie Gleason.

Not to be outdone, Hal Roach came up with TANKS A MILLION, a 50 minute wonder about a bunch of green and raw Recruits coping with the rigors of being transformed from civilians from all walks of life into Soldiers for Uncle Sam. First we had a 'great cross section of the Country' platoon of trainees featuring actors like Noah Beery, Jr., Dick Wessel, Frank Faylen and Dub Taylor. To that is added a crusty, old Commanding Officer, Colonel 'Spitfire' Barkley (Jimmy Gleason) and a high energy and efficient Company C.O. in Captain Rossmead (Douglas Fowley). In between the two, in rank anyway, was the Major Eastwood * (Veteran Silent Film Leading Man, Norman Kerry).

Now any basic training situation requires the services of a skilled, veteran Drill Instructor, a Sergeant long in the tooth, with the whiskers. Our new Platoon didn't just get any Sergeant; but their Sgt. Ames (Joe Sawyer) was an actor who seemingly made a living out of portraying these 3 Striped Non-Coms.

As a counterbalance to Ames' hard-guy Regular Army background and demeanor, we needed a meek, cerebral type. This would be a natural; fire vs. water, light & dark, Politics & Common Sense! So in among the new batch of G.I.'s, we have a former clerk with a photographic memory, Dorian Doubleday (William Tracey). 'Do-Do' Doubleday's academic skills and memory bring him nearly overnight Sergeants' Chevrons; which of course aggravated the hell out of Ames, the career man.

The stage was set and the rest of the movie plays out sort of like a Road Runner/Coyote cartoon. The next gag would no sooner hit the screen with Doubleday in the middle, we'd get reaction from the Captain, Major or Colonel and Ames would do his slow burn while 'Do-Do' manages to turn all around to his advantage.

A Lion's share of the film is devoted to sight gags, reactions, reactions to reactions and a lot of slow & fast burns and a full measure of grown men nearly crying. Much of the action plays like one of those old Silent Screen 2 Reel Comedy Shorts that Roach Studios was so famous for producing; and this is not at all a bad thing. Some prolonged scenes of physical comedy and sight gags would only have been hindered by the inclusion of any dialogue.

It must have been apparent very early on that the Doubleday & Ames combo had struck gold, caught lightening in a bottle and hit pay dirt! We suspect that the notion of doing any sequel or indeed a series would have been very 'iffy' and require evaluating TANKS A MILLION every which way. It's obvious now that they deserved a series and they did go that route. Sadly there were only Seven (7) Doubleday & Ames movies made; starting with five set in the World War II era, one back in Civilian Life and the last one being set in the Korean War in 1952.

We aren't saying that the Roach Company had to pump them out, one every 3 months as Monogram would later with their BOWERY BOYS series; but, if there had been a dozen or so movies made during the 11 year stretch, that surely wouldn't have been too many. We should be happy we have what there is from then, to now and for always.

NOTE: * The Major was given no name in the story, ergo he was 'The Man with No Name', hence the smart alecky 'Eastwood'! (Get it, Schultz!) POODLE SCHNITZ!!

Fun Stuff

[Michael_Elliott · 26 February 2008]

Tanks a Million (1941)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Hal Roach comedy has William Tracy playing a new Army recruit with a photogenic memory, which drives everyone around him crazy. It really drives Sgt. Ames (Joe Sawyer) crazy because Tracy is soon bumped up to Sgt., which took Ames twenty years to reach. This is a pretty far fetched but mildly entertaining product piece of WW2. There are several laughs throughout but nothing big enough to make me go back and watch the film. Sawyer steals the show as the jealous Sgt. and Tracy manages a few laughs as the dorky brain. The film runs fifty-minutes and that's short enough for what's going on. Any longer would have made the film a real drag. This film received an Oscar nomination for Best Scoring of a Dramatic (!?!?!) Film.

A Short Film but Still Rather Enjoyable

[Uriah43 · 6/10 · 25 February 2024]

This film essentially begins with a young man by the name of "Dorian 'Dodo' Doubleday" (William Tracy) being drafted by the United States Army and reporting for duty at his basic training site with several other fellow draftees not long afterward. It is then revealed that Private Doubleday has a photographic memory and, as a result, knows the Army regulations better than anyone. This includes the non-commissioned officer named "Sergeant Williams Ames" (Joe Sawyer) who has been tasked to train the new soldiers. Needless to say, this embarrasses Sergeant Ames who immediately decides to put him in his place. Unfortunately for Sergeant Ames, however, the officers appointed over him are quite impressed with Private Doubleday--so much so that they immediately send the young private to a non-commissioned officer course a few buildings away. To everyone's surprise, when he returns a short time later, he is now wearing the rank of First Sergeant. Absolutely enraged by this, Sergeant Ames begins to do everything he can think of to humiliate the young man. The problem, however, is that everything he tries backfires in a spectacular manner. Now, rather than reveal any more, I will just say that this film turned out much better than I initially expected due in large part to the unique solutions Dorian Doubleday used to extricate himself from one highly unlikely situation after another. Everything was totally absurd--but quite humorous at the same time. And although this is a rather short comedy, I still found it to be quite enjoyable, and I have rated it accordingly. Slightly above average.

Wow, did this little film impress me!

[planktonrules · 8/10 · 19 January 2007]

Starting in the late 1930s, Hal Roach Studios began making less and less one and two-reel shorts (such as those of Laurel and Hardy, the Little Rascals and Charley Chase) and began making short feature-length films (about 60 minutes each). This seemed to be what the public wanted, so Roach made some changes. Additionally, his old money-makers (Laurel and Hardy) went independent--working for Fox and other studios (in hindsight, NOT a good decision by the boys). So, Roach started trying to develop new talent, such as his TOPPER films and a variety of cute comedies (such as NAZTY NUISANCE and TURNABOUT). In addition, he made a short series of WWII army films about Sergeant Doubleday (starring William Tracy) and this film, TANKS A MILLION, was the first.

Before I began watching it, I thought the film had two strikes against it, so I expect it to be at best a "time passer". First, like all these Roach films, it had a small budget and secondly, I haven't yet been very impressed by ANY of these later Roach films (in general, the humor seems VERY broad and the situations VERY contrived). So, with these very low expectations, I was hard to impress. Amazingly enough, I actually was quite charmed by this little sleeper. The character of Doubleday was a very likable guy and the situations he got himself into were often hilarious. In fact, compared to other similar products of the day from other studios, this one was better than Abbott and Costello's BUCK PRIVATES (from Universal) and at least as good as Bob Hope's CAUGHT IN THE DRAFT (from Paramount).

So why did I like it? Well, part of it was Tracy and his character. He was silly and very difficult to believe, but he was also so likable and nice that I really bought into the character. Plus, his nemesis, Sgt. Ames was a great foil and watching Ames try again and again and again to catch Doubleday messing up was great--especially when again and again his sneakiness blew up in his face!! Additionally, James Gleason was a very welcome addition as the Colonel. While far from my favorite character actor, in this film, he was perfect.

The film was a great blend of comedy, WWII propaganda meant to support the war effort and entertainment. While not the funniest film of the era, it is among the best and had me wanting more. Unfortunately, one of the follow-up films in the series (ABOUT FACE) was a severe let-down. I certainly hope that HAY FOOT (1942) and the other Doubleday films (made both during WWII and the Korean War) were better.