Caught in the Fog (1928) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
May McAvoy Steals His Heart
drednm30 November 2016
This comedy thriller was originally titled FOOLS IN A FOG before being released as a silent film with talking sequences in 1928. What exists is about 40 minutes, missing the first 2 reels and the actual ending.

Story has Bob (Conrad Nagel) visiting his mother's houseboat one night and coming across a pair of burglars (May McAvoy and Charles K. Gerrard) after a famous string of pearls. How they know they are there, we don't know, since the beginning of the film is missing. As Nagel and Gerrard start to fight, an elderly couple walks in on them. They claim to be guests of the boat's owner, Mrs. Pelton (not Vickers). Of course they are crooks too, also after the pearls. They have no idea who Nagel is, so he claims to be a butler married to McAvoy the maid.

Of course Nagel and McAvoy fall for each other and each admits this is their first burglary. As the pearls are discovered and hidden over and over again by the various people, in walk a pair of detectives (Mack Swain and Hugh Herbert) who apparently are there to guard the pearls. A thick fog settles in and traps everyone aboard the houseboat. The bumblers start telling blowhard stories about their adventures, one of which is their capture of "Silk Shirt Harry" who of course is McAvoy's partner in crime (now posing as the cook).

Things reach a comic pitch when Swain decides each guest must strip so they can find the pearls once and for all. As McAvoy and Nagel hide behind a curtain, they start disrobing and throwing the clothing at Swain. McAvoy finds a suitcase of clothing and starts pelting Swain with various articles. As the clothing mounts up around a perplexed Swain, in walks Mrs. Pelton who demands that her son explain who all these people are. Film seems to end when Nagel defends McAvoy as the woman who has stolen his heart.

If there's anything after that, it's missing along with the opening reels. Seems like a fun little film, and it's a shame some of it is missing.

Note: Swain and Herbert show a business card identifying themselves as Krausschmidt and MacDonald. They are called Ryan and Riley in the credits here. The elderly couple, played by Emile Chautard and Ruth Cherrington call themselves Mr. and Mrs. Voisin.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lisping McAvoy is "thea-thick"
F Gwynplaine MacIntyre1 October 2002
"Caught in the Fog" is a po-faced treatment of material that was already spoofed quite mercilessly in Raymond Griffith's silent comedy "You'd Be Surprised". Both films have very nearly the same premise, the difference being that "Caught in the Fog" tries (and fails) to be a thriller, with comedy relief (from Mack Swain and Hugh Herbert) that overwhelms the thriller elements.

A valuable pearl necklace is stored in a safe aboard a houseboat off the Florida coast. Mrs Vickers, who owns the houseboat (and also the necklace) is absent, but her son Bob (Conrad Nagel) is aboard, disguised as his mother's butler. Among the guests aboard the houseboat are Dr Voisin (Emile Chautard) and his wife (Ruth Cherrington), a respectable French couple who are secretly jewel thieves. Also aboard is "Silk Shirt" Harry (Charles Gerrard), a jewel thief who doesn't even bother to hide the fact that he's a jewel thief. Rounding out the passenger list is pretty blonde Jane Reagan (May McAvoy), disguised as the maid. Jane is helping "Silk Shirt" to steal the necklace ... but anyone as blond and pretty as May McAvoy can't possibly be a real crook. Maybe she's secretly working for the cops...

This movie is ridiculous. The necklace vanishes from the safe almost immediately, and throughout the rest of the film it keeps popping up in vases, hollowed-out books, statuettes, and other implausible places. We're supposed to suspect everybody. The incredibly contrived plot is laughable without actually being funny.

Matters are not helped by the fact that "Caught in the Fog" is that most awkward of films: a part-talkie. May McAvoy was an extremely beautiful actress in late silent films; here, in this film's brief talking sequences, she exhibits a very weak voice with a lisp. The talkies destroyed her career. McAvoy played the female lead in the 1925 silent epic "Ben-Hur" ... and she played an extra in the 1959 remake of "Ben-Hur". Farewell, sweet silent beauty.

"Caught in the Fog" is slow, clumsy, and ludicrous. Swain and Herbert provide welcome comedy relief. The photography (by Byron Haskin) is excellent, although -- as usual for films set on shipboard -- all the sets, actors and props seem much steadier than they ought to be.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed